New York City has a rich history of connections to Italy, deeply rooted in its cultural, social, and economic fabric. These links date back to the late 19th and early 20th centuries when a significant wave of Italian immigrants arrived in New York. They settled primarily in neighborhoods like Little Italy in Manhattan, bringing with them their customs, cuisine, and traditions.
This Italian influence is evident in the city’s vibrant food scene, with countless Italian restaurants, bakeries, and cafes scattered throughout. Italian culture is also celebrated through various festivals, such as the annual Feast of San Gennaro in Little Italy, which honors the patron saint of Naples with parades, religious processions, and street food.So, if you want to try some Italian food when you’re visiting New York, we’ve rounded up some of our favorites for you to enjoy in your New York rental car. We’ve also got you covered on places to park in NYC.
Discover the Best Italian Restaurants in NYC
New York City is renowned for its diverse culinary scene, and Italian cuisine holds a special place in the hearts of many. Let’s explore some of the city’s top Italian restaurants, each offering a unique dining experience.
Carbone, Greenwich Village
Carbone is a celebrated hotspot in Greenwich Village, known for its sophisticated reinterpretations of classic Italian-American dishes. The ambiance exudes old-school charm, complete with tuxedo-clad waitstaff. The spicy rigatoni vodka is a menu highlight, a dish that has earned a cult following. Carbone’s culinary offerings are perfect for those seeking a nostalgic yet elevated dining experience.
When visiting this restaurant by rental car, nearby parking garages are available. Why not work up an appetite before your meal by visiting the nearby Washington Square Park?
L’Artusi, West Village
L’Artusi in the West Village offers a contemporary take on Italian cuisine, emphasizing fresh pasta and an impressive Italian wine list. The open kitchen and sleek decor create a vibrant and modern atmosphere. Signature dishes like the ricotta gnocchi and roasted chicken provide a delicious insight into the restaurant’s innovative approach to traditional flavors.
This Italian restaurant is the perfect spot after spending a day at Hudson River Park or The Whitney Museum of American Art. With nearby parking garages available, you can head over in your rental car after a fun-filled day.
Marea, Central Park South
Situated on the picturesque Central Park South, Marea is the epitome of fine dining, focusing on luxurious, seafood-centric Italian dishes. This Michelin-starred restaurant is ideal for special occasions, offering an exquisite menu that includes items like fusilli with octopus and bone marrow and Astice, a tantalizing dish of lobster and burrata. The elegant setting and refined service make Marea a standout destination for gourmet enthusiasts.
With a range of nearby attractions, including Central Park, Columbus Circle, and Carnegie Hall, there’s plenty to explore in this area of NYC.
Di Fara Pizza, Brooklyn
For pizza aficionados, Di Fara Pizza in Brooklyn is often hailed as one of the best pizzerias in New York City. Founded by the legendary Domenico DeMarco, this no-frills spot serves up pies that perfectly blend crispy crust, tangy tomato sauce, and high-quality cheese. Each pizza is handcrafted with care, making it a must-visit for anyone serious about their slice.
Street parking is available by this restaurant, and with the nearby attractions of Prospect Park and Brooklyn Museum, it’s well worth taking a ride over!
Babbo, Greenwich Village
Babbo is where celebrity chef Mario Batali made his mark, offering inventive Italian dishes with robust and complex flavors. Located in Greenwich Village, the restaurant’s intimate and lively atmosphere is complemented by a menu featuring standout dishes like beef cheek ravioli and black spaghetti with rock shrimp. Babbo is a testament to the creativity and depth of Italian cuisine.
Make a day of it by visiting Washington Square Park and Blue Note Jazz Club. Nearby parking garages are also available in the area.
Via Carota, West Village
Via Carota, another West Village gem, is a chic trattoria that embodies rustic Italian dining in a cozy, welcoming setting. Known for its simple yet flavorful dishes, such as cacio e pepe and braised artichokes, Via Carota offers a relaxed dining experience that feels like a slice of Italy in New York. The restaurant’s charming interior and thoughtful menu make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Nearby parking garages are available. Before devouring some delicious food, you can also visit attractions like Hudson River Park and The High Line.
Rubirosa, Nolita
Located in the heart of Nolita, Rubirosa is renowned for its thin-crust, old-school New York-style pizzas and classic Italian comfort foods. The cozy and lively atmosphere is perfect for enjoying favorites like the vodka pizza and Rubirosa Supreme. The restaurant’s dedication to quality ingredients and traditional recipes makes it a standout choice for pizza lovers.
As with most places in New York City, nearby parking garages are available. You can make a day of it by visiting the nearby New Museum and SoHo shopping district.
Mulino, Greenwich Village
For a more traditional Italian dining experience, Ilmulino in Greenwich Village offers classic dishes in a formal and attentive setting. Known for its impeccable service and timeless menu, highlights include the veal parmesan and porcini ravioli. Il Mulino’s elegant ambiance and dedication to culinary excellence make it a beloved institution for those seeking an authentic Italian meal.
After your meal, take a leisurely stroll around Washington Square Park or the New York University campus. Once again, the trusty nearby parking garages are available.
New York City’s Italian restaurant scene is as varied as it is vibrant, offering everything from classic, comforting dishes to innovative, gourmet experiences. Whether you’re in the mood for a casual pizza or a luxurious seafood feast, these establishments provide some of the city’s best Italian cuisine.
Fancy traveling farther afield? Take a look at our best restaurants in the U.S. that require a long drive and combine your two loves – driving and good food!
